
Approximately a year ago, I wrote about a study on contrafreeloading that one of my students, Gabriella Smith, had done with The Alex Foundation for her MA work at Hunter College. Contrafreeloading is extremely interesting because it is pretty much unexpected—it involves working for food that could simultaneously be obtained for free, and why would anyone work for something if they didn’t need to do so?
Well, a range of species engage in this behavior to some extent; we hypothesized that it would occur if the task actually is something fun so that the subjects get the double reward of doing something they enjoy and getting some food they would also like. Indeed, we found that African grey parrots would engage in contrafreeloading when they view the task not as work but rather as some kind of play (Smith et al., 2021).
We tested Griffin and Athena in our lab, Pepper and Franco (companion African greys to the Hartsfields, birds who have also been tested in some of our previous experiments), and Lucci (a companion African grey to one of our research assistants) and used two tasks: Experiment 1 involved a small container that could have a loosely attached lid that the parrot could flip off in order to receive a reward. Treats (sometimes of equal desirability and sometimes of differing desirability) were placed in covered or uncovered cups; the latter were “free.”
Experiment 2 involved the choice between a nut still in its shell (i.e., one that required some work to obtain) and an already shelled, “free” nut. The first experiment was “artificial,” in the sense that the specific conditions would never be experienced in nature. The second was “ecological,” in that it reproduced something African grey parrots face in their daily lives in the wild.
To sum up and repeat what we found: What was clear was that for Griffin, lid-popping was fun—he would even pop a lid on an empty container in preference to eating a less favored treat!—and cracking nutshells was work. But the opposite was true for Athena and Franco, who consistently avoided lids but chose the nut with the shell. Pepper didn’t much enjoy lid-popping either; she and Lucci also thought nutshell cracking was work. Interestingly, it was also clear that all four birds in Experiment 1 (Lucci did only Experiment 2) were willing to work a bit (i.e., pop a lid) if it meant getting a more favored food than the food they could have for free (what we called “calculated contrafreeloading”).
Kea’s Come Into the Mix

However, the research didn’t end there. Smith had attended a conference where she fortuitously met some researchers who study kea—fortuitously, because kea parrots are purportedly much more playful birds than African grey parrots (e.g., Auersperg et al., 2014; Diamond & Bond, 2004). What if we gave the same tasks to the kea? We hypothesized that, being more playful, they would contrafreeload overall more than the Greys. We were partially correct.
We found that, at the group level, although the overall amounts of kea classic contrafreeloading were nonsignificant (to be expected, given that the behavior is basically unlikely and fairly rare—see Menzel, 1991 and Smith et al., 2021), as a percentage of behavior, kea generally contrafreeloaded more than Grey parrots in Experiment 1, whereas the opposite was true for Experiment 2. It turned out that none of the kea chose to crack the shell of the nut (Smith et al., 2022)!
Differing Results
Why was there such a difference in behavior for Experiment 2? Well, we had decided to give the kea the exact same tasks as the African greys so that we could perform a direct comparison of their actions; however, it turns out that kea parrots, although they are indeed playful and eat a very wide variety of foods (Diamond & Bond, 2004), rarely if ever crack nuts in nature! So, the task was not ecologically valid for them—not something they would normally do; maybe they didn’t even recognize the shell as something that contained food.
Should we have used some activity that was more natural for them, like scrounging? This question is typical of some of the difficult decisions that have to be made when doing an experiment—had we used a more ecologically relevant task for the kea, they probably would have engaged in it more, but then we wouldn’t have had a direct comparison with the African greys. The solution is that, at some point, we—or some other laboratory—will have to run a separate experiment on kea parrots, using a truly ecologically relevant task, to see what will happen.

For now, we are re-running Experiment 2 with some cockatoos that live in a sanctuary near the home of one of my undergraduates. The reason is that cockatoos are also purportedly more playful than African greys (Auersperg et al., 2014) and routinely shell nuts. We’ll report the data when we complete our analyses, but it looks as though the cockatoos are more like the Greys,—that some enjoy nut-cracking and will contrafreeload, whereas others do not (Carroll et al., in prep).
In any case, we think we have provided some decent data to show that contrafreeloading, which really shouldn’t actually occur at all, will happen if the subject finds the task at least somewhat enjoyable. Hey…think about all the humans who spend time with video games, where the only ‘reward’ is likely some flashing lights that they could also likely see for free!
References
Auersperg, A.M.I., Oswald, N., Domanegg, M., Gajdon, G.K. & Bugnyar, T. (2014). Unrewarded object combinations in captive parrots. Anim. Behav. Cogn. 1, 470-488.
Carroll, A, Gray, S.L, & Pepperberg, I.M. (in prep). Contrafreeloading in cockatoos.
Diamond, J. & Bond, A.B. (2004). Social play in kaka (Nestor meridionalis) with comparisons to kea (Nestor notabilis). Behaviour, 141, 777–798 (2004).
Menzel, E.W. (1991). Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes): Problem seeking versus the bird-in-hand, least-effort strategy. Primates, 32, 497–508.
Smith, G.E., Bastos, A.P.M., Taylor, A.H., & Pepperberg, I.M., (2022). Contrafreeloading in kea (Nestor notabilis) in comparison to Grey parrots (Psittacus erithacus). Sci. Rpts. 12:17415
Smith, G.E., Greene, D., Hartsfield, L.A., & Pepperberg, I.M. (2021). Initial evidence for contrafreeloading in Grey parrots via the opportunity for playful foraging. J. Comp. Psychol. 135, 516-533 doi: 10.1037com0000295.







Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest, Lisa Bono, CPBC, owner and operator of The Platinum Parrot and a certified parrot behavior consultant specializing in African grey parrots, presents Episode 15 of The Grey Way, a Lafeber Pet Birds Webinar Series focusing on Congo & Timneh African grey parrots as pets. In this fun holiday episode, Lisa will discuss different ways to cater to your pet birds and give them their own holiday fun & feasting! This is about what they CAN have, and not about what they can’t. She will give the viewers ideas for holiday-themed activities and toys as well as seasonal foods your birds can enjoy. Get ready to plan your own special holiday fun for your birds this season!
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest, Dr. Stephanie Lamb, DVM, DABVP (Avian Practice), will discuss holiday hazards for pet birds. The holidays are a busy time for everyone, but they can be particularly busy for a Veterinary clinic due to all of the dangers for our pets that can come up during the festivities. Anything from decorations to food to guests in your home can result in a trip to the Vet for your pet birds. Learn about some of the things to watch for, & holiday-related cases that Vets treat in this insider’s view of the holiday happenings at your Avian Vet’s clinic.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest Tom Tully, DVM, DABVP (Avian Practice), DECZM (Avian), joins us once again to answer your questions about pet bird health, nutrition, & care.

Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest, Dr. Joerg Mayer DVM, MS, DABVP(ECM), DECZM, DACZM, Professor, joins us again from the University of Georgia College of Veterinary Medicine where he works in Small Animal Medicine & Surgery, Veterinary Teaching Hospital & Zoological Medicine Service. The often hilarious and always entertaining Dr. Mayer will talk about his experiences with treating Exotics, which includes parrots and other bird species as well as exotic mammal & reptile species. His work includes research, new advances in Avian & Exotics Medicine and teaching the next generation of Avian & Exotics Veterinarians. Join us for another fascinating look into Dr. Mayer’s experiences & what goes on at a University Vet College & Vet Hospital – interesting cases, how new medicines and treatments are discovered and how important specialty Vets are for helping our exotic pets live better & longer lives.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest, Lisa Bono, CPBC, owner and operator of The Platinum Parrot and a certified parrot behavior consultant specializing in African grey parrots, presents Episode 14 of The Grey Way, a Lafeber Pet Birds Webinar Series focusing on Congo & Timneh African grey parrots as pets. In this episode, Lisa will talk about feeding your pet bird. This isn’t another nutrition webinar, but rather a fun approach to offering a variety of healthy foods to your pet bird. My bird won’t touch that! Sound familiar? Lisa is going to show you ways to entice even the pickiest parrot to try something new. While Lisa will address Grey-centric concerns, her feeding tips can apply to any pet bird.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest, Dr. Stephanie Lamb, DVM, DABVP (Avian Practice), will join us Live from Costa Rica, along with Dr. Sol Delechuk, the manager of the breeding center. Dr. Lamb will talk about her experiences volunteering at the center for a week. Dr. Sol has extensive experience as a veterinarian, caretaker, trainer, field biologist, and more, and joined the Punta Islita team as Bird Manager in September 2021. She will tell us about the center and its goals and accomplishments. We are beyond excited to be able to present such a valuable conservation project, live from the field, to celebrate our 100th webinar! This is such a special opportunity made possible by Lafeber Company! There will be some fun giveaways, too, so don’t miss this very special event!
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest Tom Tully, DVM, DABVP (Avian Practice), DECZM (Avian), will answer your questions about pet bird health, nutrition, & care.
Timneh greys (Psittacus timneh) are found in parts of west Africa such as Sierra Leone, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Liberia, and Côte d’Ivoire. Exact numbers are unknown (estimated 100,000-500,000), but they are decidedly decreasing due to trapping and habitat loss, the usual challenges for parrot conservation.
During 2021-2022, the WPT has continued developing several important conservation activities focused in Sierra Leone. First, 239 people in 70 communities were surveyed to develop knowledge, discern attitudes, and learn about the distribution and abundance of the Timnehs. By listening to local communities and leveraging local ecological knowledge, WPT has been able to build a picture of seasonal movements and identify roost and nesting areas throughout the region. This has highlighted the vital importance of mangrove areas and built a strong case for protection of several key sites.
One roost that was identified during this work holds several hundred parrots and is the largest known roost for the species on the African mainland. This was an extremely exciting finding and suggests that in some remote areas, Timneh populations may still be relatively healthy. However numerous threats including trapping of adults and the collection of eggs have been identified. This can only get worse as land is further developed. Protection of these remote sites is essential!
Lastly, a radio jingle and announcement communicating positive messages about parrot conservation has been regularly played on local radio stations. These have been accompanied by live radio interviews with government officials answering questions about the need to protect Timneh parrots. These type of activities must continue and be regularly reinforced to be successful.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest, Lisa Bono, CPBC, owner and operator of The Platinum Parrot and a certified parrot behavior consultant specializing in African grey parrots, presents Episode 13 of The Grey Way, a Lafeber Pet Birds Webinar Series focusing on Congo & Timneh African grey parrots as pets. In this episode, Lisa will discuss and demonstrate ways to exercise your parrot! Avian Vets and experts all agree that pet birds do not get enough exercise, and this leads to medical issues over time. But most bird owners are unsure of how to encourage their birds to exercise. Lisa will cover different ways to exercise your bird – whether the bird is flighted or clipped, cage bound or has a physical disability. While Lisa will cover some Grey-centric methods, all species of pet birds can benefit from her suggestions. Don’t miss this opportunity to help your pet birds live happier & healthier lives.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest Tom Tully, DVM, DABVP (Avian Practice), DECZM (Avian), will answer your questions about pet bird health, nutrition, & care. Dr. Tully, a decorated Professor & practicing Vet at Louisiana State University School of Veterinary Medicine, is an internationally known Veterinarian who has earned specialties in Avian medicine in the United States as well as in Europe. Having this type of access to a Veterinarian of his status is rare, but Dr. Tully believes in the educated bird owner as being the best bird steward. Dr. Tully answers each question in detail and shares his vast knowledge of birds, particularly parrots. Is your bird’s problem health-related or behavioral? Are you offering the right foods to your pet bird? Ask the Vet!




Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest, Lisa Bono, CPBC, owner and operator of The Platinum Parrot and a certified parrot behavior consultant specializing in African grey parrots, presents Episode 12 of The Grey Way, a Lafeber Pet Birds Webinar Series focusing on Congo & Timneh African grey parrots as pets. By viewer request, in this episode, Lisa will tell us more about herself, and how she manages a multi-bird household. Many of our viewers have wondered how she maintains her flock of African Greys – keeping things clean & most importantly, keeping the peace! We will learn more about Lisa’s background in parrots and how she learned to be such an awesome steward for her own flock, as well as advising others on how to care for their pet birds. While Lisa now specializes in African Greys, we will learn that her life with parrots didn’t begin with Greys. This will be a fun and fascinating look at Lisa’s world, and include meeting her flock – if they choose to cooperate!
Join us for a live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guests, Lisa Bono, CPBC, Ann Brooks, and Dr. Susan Orosz will discuss education as the key to being the best bird steward. Lisa will report on the most recent Phoenix Landing Wellness Retreat, which was held June 4-5, 2022 in Asheville, NC. This unique meeting for pet bird owners offers lectures on many aspects of pet bird care. Lisa will discuss the speakers and topics and what goes on at a meeting like this, as well as why it is important for bird owners and professionals to continue learning through different avenues. Ann Brooks will join her to talk about Phoenix Landing, how it came about and why adoption or re-homing are so necessary for parrots. Dr. Susan Orosz will tell us how the idea for this special learning opportunity came about and how it became a place for learning from experts in the field as well as fellow bird owners. This will be the first-of-its-kind discussion for us, featuring three top experts in the field of companion birds, combining their expertise in education, rescue & Avian medicine. We look forward to having viewers join us for this rare treat!












Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for this very important FREE, live webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for a live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.

Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for a live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine. Our special guest, 












Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for this very important FREE, live webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.







Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for a FREE, live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.
Join us for a live, interactive webinar hosted by Laura Doering, former editor of Bird Talk magazine and Birds USA magazine.